Contenu du sommaire : Les territoires de montagne, fournisseurs mondiaux de ressources

Revue Revue de Géographie Alpine Mir@bel
Numéro vol. 103, no 3, 2015
Titre du numéro Les territoires de montagne, fournisseurs mondiaux de ressources
Texte intégral en ligne Accessible sur l'internet
  • Mountains as Global Suppliers : New Forms of Disparities Between Mountain Areas and Metropolitan Hubs - Manfred Perlik accès libre
  • Les territoires de montagne comme fournisseurs mondiaux de ressources : nouvelles formes de disparités entre montagnes et pôles métropolitains - Manfred Perlik accès libre
  • Trajectoires territoriales d'un nouveau centre extractif mondialisé. L'exemple des Andes argentines septentrionales - Marie Forget accès libre avec résumé avec résumé en anglais
    L'activité minière en Argentine est devenue très dynamique et essentielle pour l'économie du pays, plaçant la cordillère des Andes, au cœur des problématiques économiques, politiques et sociales, provinciales et nationales. Cet article propose donc d'interroger la division spatiale du travail et le rôle attribué aux territoires andins dans le Nord-ouest de l'Argentine. La spécialisation des territoires de montagne comme des réservoirs de matières premières minières, bien acceptée au début du siècle, est aujourd'hui remise en cause du fait du faible développement territorial qu'elle induit. La re-primarisation des économies latino-américaines semble reproduire des formes d'exploitation coloniale qui interroge les relations Nord-Sud et les modalités de développement de territoires encore largement marginaux, pauvres et peu peuplés. Les trajectoires territoriales de trois provinces – San Juan, Catamarca et Jujuy – permettront d'analyser le rôle des acteurs étatiques et non étatiques dans la construction de la ressource et des valeurs qui lui sont attribuées. Ces interactions interrogent les modèles de développement des territoires de montagne, qui de « fournisseurs globaux » intègrent progressivement les problématiques de développement territorial à l'échelle locale.
    Argentina's mining industry has grown rapidly in recent years, making the sector an essential part of the country's economy and placing the Andes at the heart of numerous economic, political and social issues. The present article examines the spatial distribution of mining activities and the role attributed to the mountains of northwest Argentina. Exploiting these territories as reservoirs of raw materials was uncontroversial at the beginning of the century; however, this approach is now being contested because it leads to little territorial development. Latin America's renewed focus on primary industries, involving the extraction and export of unprocessed natural resources, could be viewed as a step back to colonial-style exploitation. As such, it raises questions about North-South relations and the development of mountain territories, which are often peripheral, poor and sparsely populated. Our research examines the territorial-development trajectories of three provinces - San Juan, Catamarca and Jujuy – and analyzes how interactions between governmental and non-governmental actors affect a territory's approach to constructing and exploiting its resources. Questions about the way in which these interactions shape the development of mountain territories have led to alternative models that take into account the need for territorial development to be built locally.
  • Territorial Trajectories within a New Centre for the Globalised Mining Industry: the Andes of Northern Argentina - Marie Forget accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    Argentina's mining industry has grown rapidly in recent years, making the sector an essential part of the country's economy and placing the Andes at the centre of numerous economic, political and social issues. This article examines the spatial distribution of mining activities and the role attributed to the mountains of northwest Argentina. Exploiting these territories as reservoirs of raw materials was uncontroversial at the beginning of the century; however, this approach is now being contested because it leads to little territorial development. Latin America's renewed focus on primary industries involving the extraction and export of unprocessed natural resources can be viewed as a step back to colonial-style exploitation. As such, it raises questions about North–South relations and the development of mountain territories, which are often peripheral, poor and sparsely populated. Our research examines the territorial-development trajectories of three provinces – San Juan, Catamarca and Jujuy – and analyses how interactions between governmental and non-governmental actors affect a territory's approach to constructing and exploiting its resources. Questions about the way in which these interactions shape the development of mountain territories have led to alternative models that take into account the need for territorial development to be built locally.
  • L'eau de Chartreuse, miroir réfléchissant du renouvellement des dialectiques territoriales entre villes et montagne - Bérangère Serroi, François Besancenot, Philippe Brégard, Gérard Hanus, Fabien Hobléa accès libre avec résumé avec résumé en anglais
    Le Parc naturel régional de Chartreuse est souvent perçu comme un réservoir d'eau brute à destination de ses piémonts. Bien que la ressource soit abondante, les effets actuels et attendus du changement climatique se traduisent d'ores et déjà par des pressions émergentes entre différents usages de l'eau. Ces nouveaux enjeux pesant sur la ressource en eau interrogent la dialectique ville/montagne, et sa déclinaison classique au travers du prisme centre-périphérie. Cet article s'appuie notamment sur l'exemple des pratiques de transfert d'eau inter bassins versants pour analyser les nouvelles stratégies de gestion adoptées par les collectivités, et explorer les complémentarités possibles, dans un contexte de rapport de force entre gestion privée et gestion publique, pour tendre vers une logique de solidarité et de sécurisation des systèmes d'approvisionnement.
    The Chartreuse Regional Nature Park is often considered a raw water reservoir for its borderlands. Although it is an abundant resource, current and expected impacts of climate change are already reflected in the emerging pressures on different water uses. These new challenges imposed on water resources raise questions about the relationships between urban and mountain areas, typically considered through the centre/periphery paradigm. In particular, this article deals with the question of transfers between water basins. In so doing, it analyses the new management strategies that communities have adopted and explores possible synergies against a backdrop of the power relationship between private and public management in order to move towards an approach that embraces solidarity and security of supply.
  • Water in the Chartreuse, a mirror reflecting a renewal of relationships between mountains areas and their surrounding towns - Bérangère Serroi, François Besancenot, Philippe Brégard, Gérard Hanus, Fabien Hobléa accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    The Chartreuse Regional Nature Park is often considered a raw water reservoir for its borderlands. Although it is an abundant resource, current and expected impacts of climate change are already reflected in the emerging pressures on different water uses. These new challenges imposed on water resources raise questions about the relationships between urban and mountain areas, typically considered through the centre/periphery paradigm. In particular, this article deals with the question of transfers between water basins. In so doing, it analyses the new management strategies that communities have adopted and explores possible synergies against a backdrop of the power relationship between private and public management in order to move towards an approach that embraces solidarity and security of supply.
  • Des flots à contre-courant : des montagnes du Lesotho à la métropole sud-africaine - Yannick Rousselot accès libre avec résumé avec résumé en anglais
    Cet article aborde les territoires de montagne comme fournisseurs en eau pour la métropole du Gauteng au travers du cas du Lesotho Highlands Water Project (LHWP) – projet de transfert hydraulique transfrontalier entre le Lesotho et l'Afrique du Sud. Cela permettra d'articuler les enjeux hydropolitiques aux questions de territorialités. Le LHWP a donné lieu à la reproduction de relations asymétriques entre et au sein des territoires métropolitains et montagneux des deux pays. Des coalitions entre acteurs ont émergé des relations que ces transferts ont instituées. A ce titre, ce projet peut être analysé en tant qu'agencement hydraulique où s'articule ou se confronte trois différentes échelles de territorialités : celle régionaliste des élites économiques et politiques sud-africaines contemporaines, de concentration des ressources hydrauliques d'Afrique Australe au profit de l' « assoiffée » région de Johannesburg ; celle du gouvernement de l'Etat du Lesotho : d'une politique nationaliste de monopolisation des enjeux socio-spatiaux au profit de la seule échelle nationale ; celle des communautés basotho : d'autonomie par rapport aux interventions de l'Etat et de revendication d'une nation basotho transnationale.
    The aim of this article is to consider the mountains of Lesotho as suppliers of water to the Gauteng metropolitan area in South Africa. By analysing the hydropolitics of the Southern African region in the context of politics of scale, the focus is on the Lesotho Highlands Water Project (LHWP), a transboundary water transfer project between Lesotho and South Africa. The goal is to link hydropolitics with territorialities. The LHWP has resulted in a reproduction of the asymmetrical relations between and inside the metropolitan and mountain areas of both countries. Coalitions of actors have emerged from these new relations that the transfer has produced, and as such, this project should be analysed as a hydraulic assemblage in which three distinct scales of territorialities are clashing or cooperating with each other: the regional scale, made up of South Africa's political and economic elites, who seek to direct Southern Africa's water resources towards the thirsty region in and around Johannesburg; the scale of the Lesotho government, which has a nationalist policy of monopolising any social and spatial stakes for the benefit of the national territory; and the scale of the Maloti communities, which claim their rights as a transnational Basotho nation and autonomy in the face of interventionism from the Lesotho state.
  • Upstream Flows of Water: from the Lesotho Highlands to Metropolitan South Africa - Yannick Rousselot accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    The aim of this article is to consider the mountains of Lesotho as suppliers of water to the Gauteng metropolitan area in South Africa. By analysing the hydropolitics of the Southern African region in the context of politics of scale, the focus is on the Lesotho Highlands Water Project (LHWP), a transboundary water transfer project between Lesotho and South Africa. The goal is to link hydropolitics with territorialities. The LHWP has resulted in a reproduction of the asymmetrical relations between and inside the metropolitan and mountain areas of both countries. Coalitions of actors have emerged from these new relations that the transfer has produced, and as such, this project should be analysed as a hydraulic assemblage in which three distinct scales of territorialities are clashing or cooperating with each other: the regional scale, made up of South Africa's political and economic elites, who seek to direct Southern Africa's water resources towards the thirsty region in and around Johannesburg; the scale of the Lesotho government, which has a nationalist policy of monopolising any social and spatial stakes for the benefit of the national territory; and the scale of the Maloti communities, which claim their rights as a transnational Basotho nation and autonomy in the face of interventionism from the Lesotho state.
  • Local Transformations and New Economic Functionalities Generated by Amenity Migration in Northern Chilean Patagonia - Carla Marchant, Fernanda Rojas accès libre avec résumé avec résumé en anglais
    La migration d'agrément vers les régions montagneuses du sud du Chili est un phénomène qui s'est largement étendu ces dernières décennies et qui contribue notoirement au changement de ces espaces ruraux, espaces qui ont été encore peu étudiés par les chercheurs. Dans cet article, nous présentons le résultat de nos observations sur les transformations économiques et sociales à Malalcahuello, village montagneux de la Patagonie du nord. Ce village se trouve précisément à un stade émergent de ce processus de migration. L'arrivée de nouveaux acteurs économiques et la migration d'agrément vers cet espace rural, traditionnellement marginalisé par rapport aux circuits économiques nationaux, ont créé un renouveau pour ce village et développé de nouvelles fonctions économiques au service du développement résidentiel et touristique. Ces nouvelles activités représentent une opportunité et à la fois un défi pour le futur développement de ce village de montagne en tant que destination touristique. De même, nous avons observé des changements dans les dynamiques sociales, spécialement influencées par l'arrivée des nouveaux habitants qui possèdent les outils nécessaires au développement d'activités liées à la protection de l'environnement et du territoire, ce qui implique la réévaluation de celui-ci par les habitants traditionnels.
    Amenity migration in the mountain regions of southern Chile is a phenomenon that academia has not analysed very often. However, it has gained greater prominence in recent years and is becoming an important factor in generating change in these rural areas. This paper presents the results of the economic and social transformations observed in Malalcahuello, a mountain village in northern Chilean Patagonia that finds itself in an emerging stage of this process. The arrival of new economic actors, together with amenity, has produced a revival in the village and developed new economic functions, now aimed at developing residential real estate and special interest tourism. These activities represent an opportunity and also a challenge for the future development of this mountain village as a tourist destination. Furthermore, changes in social dynamics have been observed and influenced by the new inhabitants in particular, who possess the means to take action to protect the environment and the territory. This has provoked a re-evaluation of the territory, in part by the traditional inhabitants.
  • Transformaciones locales y nuevas funcionalidades económicas vinculadas a las migraciones por amenidad en la Patagonia chilena - Carla Marchant, Fernanda Rojas accès libre
  • Condomini di montagna. Una riflessione sugli insediamenti e sull'abitare nei contesti periurbani di una città alpina - Cristina Mattiucci accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    By examining the settlement typology and the relationship between the people and the landscape where they have chosen to dwell, this paper investigates the territorial transformation processes in Roncegno Terme, a small town in the Italian province of Trento, which can be considered a paradigmatic context for metropolitan-mountain development. Starting from the model of housing that the town has been generating, we ask whether these processes manifest the features of a monofunctional residential transformation and examine the effects it may have on the transformation of the inhabited mountain and the genesis of spatial homogeneity and possible spatial inequalities. This reflection is based on a critical reading of field work carried out during an urban planning experience, and the case study is presented with the phenomenal and empirical data collected during a study about landscape perception, conceived as a structural survey to propose socially shared planning processes and territorial transformations. One of the main issues that this article tackles is the possible correlation between the shape of the newer buildings that have been erected in some areas of town and the transformation of a peri-urban mountain reality that tends to gradually take on the features of a dormitory town. The paper therefore intends to make explicit the link between the densification of the building processes and the dissolution of the collective spaces. In so doing, at the present stage of an as yet incomplete densification of the mountain settlements, we work under the assumption that this survey can be useful to reflect on the possibilities of the planning and territorial governance tools to correct the territorial disparities that might be generated when small mountain towns turn into mostly residential suburbs of the metropolitan centres nearby.
  • Mountain Condominiums. A Discussing of Settlement and Dwelling on the Outskirts of an Alpine City - Cristina Mattiucci accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    By examining the settlement typology and the relationship between the people and the landscape where they have chosen to dwell, this paper investigates the territorial transformation processes in Roncegno Terme, a small town in the Italian province of Trento, which can be considered a paradigmatic context for metropolitan-mountain development. Starting from the model of housing that the town has been generating, we ask whether these processes manifest the features of a monofunctional residential transformation and examine the effects it may have on the transformation of the inhabited mountain and the genesis of spatial homogeneity and possible spatial inequalities.This reflection is based on a critical reading of field work carried out during an urban planning experience, and the case study is presented with the phenomenal and empirical data collected during a study about landscape perception, conceived as a structural survey to propose socially shared planning processes and territorial transformations.One of the main issues that this article tackles is the possible correlation between the shape of the newer buildings that have been erected in some areas of town and the transformation of a peri-urban mountain reality that tends to gradually take on the features of a dormitory town. The paper therefore intends to make explicit the link between the densification of the building processes and the dissolution of the collective spaces. In so doing, at the present stage of an as yet incomplete densification of the mountain settlements, we work under the assumption that this survey can be useful to reflect on the possibilities of the planning and territorial governance tools to correct the territorial disparities that might be generated when small mountain towns turn into mostly residential suburbs of the metropolitan centres nearby.
  • Impact of Conservation and Development on the Vicinity of Nanda Devi National Park in the North India - Pratiba Naitthani, Sunil Kainthola accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    Both the hydropower and the conservation sectors are concentrating their focus on the Himalayas, which have high hydropower potential and rich bio-cultural diversity. The aim of this present study, carried out in villages adjacent to the Nanda Devi National Park in the Himalayan state of Uttarakhand in India, is to understand the linkages between conservation- and development-induced displacement and the process of designing compensation packages for the local community. The study also examines the various gender-specific impacts of displacement, and the results suggest significant gender-specific differences regarding the impact of displacement in critical respects. The findings further indicate that, despite an early recommendation to do so, no impact assessment study had been conducted prior to the notification of the area as a national park. Furthermore, there appears to be no systematic linkage between the compensatory schemes and the grievances of the impacted communities.
  • Protected Areas in the Slovak Carpathians as a Contested Resource Between Metropolitan and Mountain Stakeholders - Heino Meessen, Juraj Švajda, Thomas Kohler, Vladimíra Fabriciusová, Dobromil Galvánek, Miroslav Buraľ, Marcela Káčerová, Ján Kadlečík accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    In Eastern Europe's westernmost mountain region, the Carpathians, the Slovak State Nature Conservancy is preserving a unique biodiversity in line with directives of the European Union. This is being done in large protected areas (LPAs). In this paper, we discuss current challenges of LPA management with a particular focus on contradictions between local people's views and nationally to internationally determined sectoral planning strategies. We take stock of the benefits LPAs offer local populations, analyse the reasons for conflict between conservation interests from outside the region and local people's vital needs, and explore ways of uncovering, tackling, and solving land use conflicts at the interface of national or international conservation interests and sustainable local development. Slovak and Swiss universities (Banská Bystrica, Žilina, and Bern) and nature conservation partners adapted, tested, and analysed a transdisciplinary research approach to mitigate land use conflicts in and around LPAs. . A joint Slovak–Swiss financing mechanism enabled Slovak project partners to implement small innovative projects proposed by local stakeholders – so-called Seed Money Actions (SMAs). First results show that this might be a fruitful new form of cooperation between protected area managers and local populations, as it may ultimately lead to a higher acceptance of nature conservation among locals while offering Slovak mountain farmers more tangible benefits from nearby protected areas.
  • Grossschutzgebiete in den slowakischen Karpaten als Kompensation urbaner Verdichtung - Heino Meessen, Juraj Švajda, Thomas Kohler, Vladimíra Fabriciusová, Dobromil Galvánek, Miroslav Buraľ, Marcela Káčerová, Ján Kadlečík accès libre avec résumé avec résumé en anglais
    Dans les Carpates, partie occidentale du massif montagneux de l'Europe de l'Est, l‘autorité slovaque de protection de la nature s'efforce de protéger une biodiversité unique selon les directives de protection de la nature de l'UE. Dans l'article ci-dessous, les auteurs discutent en particulier des contradictions entre exigences de la protection de la nature internationale et intérêts des populations locales dans les grandes aires protégées de l'est de la Slovaquie. Nous présentons ainsi des démarches concrètes qui permettent d'aborder et même de résoudre ces conflits déclenchés par des mesures de protection strictes. Dans le contexte des hêtraies primaires des grandes aires de protection slovaques, nous analysons les zones de convergence entre les intérêts de protection de la nature nationaux et internationaux et un développement local durable pour et par les populations locales. C'est grâce à une approche de recherche transdisciplinaire que des universités slovaques et suisses (Banská  Bystrica, Žilina, et Berne) et des organisations partenaires de la protection de la nature ont développé un concept concret qu'elles ont adapté aux pratiques de gestion slovaques et ensuite testé. Ce processus a nécessité le développement en parallèle d'un mécanisme de financement pour de petits projets innovants réalisables dans ou à proximité des grandes aires protégées étudiées. Cet instrument de capital initial a été intitulé « Seed Money Actions (SMA) ».
    In Eastern Europe's westernmost mountain region, the Carpathians, the Slovak State Nature Conservancy is preserving a unique biodiversity in line with directives of the European Union. This is being done in large protected areas (LPAs). In this paper, we discuss current challenges of LPA management with a particular focus on contradictions between local people's views and nationally to internationally determined sectoral planning strategies. We take stock of the benefits LPAs offer local populations, analyse the reasons for conflict between conservation interests from outside the region and local people's vital needs, and explore ways of uncovering, tackling, and solving land use conflicts at the interface of national or international conservation interests and sustainable local development. Slovak and Swiss universities (Banská Bystrica, Žilina, and Bern) and nature conservation partners adapted, tested, and analysed a transdisciplinary research approach to mitigate land use conflicts in and around LPAs. . A joint Slovak–Swiss financing mechanism enabled Slovak project partners to implement small innovative projects proposed by local stakeholders – so-called Seed Money Actions (SMAs). First results show that this might be a fruitful new form of cooperation between protected area managers and local populations, as it may ultimately lead to a higher acceptance of nature conservation among locals while offering Slovak mountain farmers more tangible benefits from nearby protected areas.
  • Planification stratégique et asymétries territoriales. Grenoble et le Grand Genève, deux régions urbaines alpines à l'épreuve de la cohérence. - Nathalie Bertrand, Dominik Cremer-Schulte, Mathieu Perrin accès libre avec résumé avec résumé en anglais
    La cohérence territoriale est aujourd'hui l'un des principes directeurs des démarches de planification, et ce en particulier à l'échelle des régions urbaines. Ainsi, la multiplication des initiatives de planification sur ces périmètres élargis pourrait laisser espérer un renouvellement des rapports entre villes, périphéries et espaces ruraux. Cet article a pour objectif de montrer que les processus de gouvernance mis en œuvre dans le cadre de démarches de planification territoriale à l'échelle de régions urbaines alpines tendent cependant à révéler, voire à entretenir, des disparités entre territoires urbains et périphériques, notamment montagnards. Leurs capacités à peser sur le projet territorial et les orientations aménagistes s'avèrent inégales, en raison notamment de capitaux – financier, social, humain et institutionnel – répartis de manière hétérogène. Sur la base des documents de planification et de matériel oral, la démonstration s'appuie sur deux projets territoriaux alpins, le Grand Genève et le schéma de cohérence territoriale (SCoT) de la région grenobloise.
    Territorial cohesion is today a guiding principle of spatial planning, especially at city region scale. Given the extension of city region perimeters, the relationships between cities, outskirts and rural areas could undergo a renewal. The objective of this article is to show that governance processes in the framework of strategic spatial planning projects tend to reveal, or even to maintain, disparities between urban and peripheral territories, especially in mountain areas. Their capacities to influence the territorial projects turn out to be unequal, as territories do not have the same resources (financial, social, human and institutional capitals). On the basis of spatial planning documents and interviews, the article analyses two alpine city region planning initiatives, Greater Geneva and Grenoble city region.
  • Strategic Spatial Planning and Territorial Asymmetries. Grenoble and Greater Geneva: Two Alpine City Regions Put to the Challenge of Coherence - Nathalie Bertrand, Dominik Cremer-Schulte, Mathieu Perrin accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    Territorial coherence is today a guiding principle of spatial planning, especially at the city-region scale. The increasing number of spatial planning initiatives on such extended perimeters comes with the hope of a renewed relationship between cities, outskirts and rural areas. The aim of this article is to show that the governance processes at work in strategic spatial planning projects tend to reveal, or even to maintain, disparities between urban and peripheral areas, especially in mountain regions. Such areas' ability to influence spatial projects proves to be uneven since they have different resources (financial, social, human and institutional). Based on spatial planning documents and interviews, the research reported in this article analyses the planning initiatives in two alpine city regions: Greater Geneva and Grenoble.