Contenu du sommaire : De l'agricole au paysage
Revue | Etudes rurales |
---|---|
Numéro | no 121-124, 1991 |
Titre du numéro | De l'agricole au paysage |
Texte intégral en ligne | Accessible sur l'internet |
- Avertissement - Pierre Lamaison p. 7
De l'agricole au paysage
- Quelques notes pour une histoire de la sensibilité au paysage - Georges Duby p. 11-14
- Paysagismes - Gilles Sautter p. 15-20
- Pour une grammaire du paysage agraire - Isac Chiva p. 21-26
- Le paysage rural : la couleur de l'agricole, la saveur de l'agricole, mais que reste-t-il de l'agricole ? - Yves Luginbühl p. 27-44 The Rural Landscape : The Color and Flavor of Agriculture : But What Is Left of Agriculture ? This analysis of iconographs of the landscape sheds light on how signs of fanning activities are vanishing in painting, lithographs and illustrations in general. This vanishing tangibly signals that the social elite has appropriated the countryside and is composing a landscape in conformity with its aesthetic aspirations. By interpreting surveys conducted in various areas, we can see the landscape's place in relation to the countryside in residents' perceptions ; and we can also assess the impact of "landscape models" on their mental representations.
- Que reste-t-il de 3 000 ans de création paysagère ? - Gérard Chouquer p. 45-58 What Remains from 3000 Years of Landscape Creation ? Research on rural landscapes is based on the idea that the latter have their origins in the Middle Ages. Archeological prospecting and excavations, and even more the archeology of landscape forms, provides evidence that the period from the Neolithic till the end of the Roman Empire accounts for much of the form of existing landscapes. Since ancient times, the land has been registered : these overlapping cadasters have definitively helped shape landscapes. The Feudal Ages "dressed" the landscape in new ways (open fields and groves), and added its own creations, but did not alter the land's fundamental structures.
- Haie sèche, haie vive et ronce artificielle - Patrice Notteghem p. 59-72 Dry Hedges, Quickset Hedges and Artificial Brambles Types of bocages (groves) are usually described in terms of land divisions and hedge networks. Much less attention is paid to the makeup of the hedges and even less to their structure. The characteristics of various bocages have been strongly marked by changes in the techniques for setting, using and keeping up hedges made up of thickets of interplanted bushes and trees. These practices, whether maintained, adapted or abandoned, reflect the functions attributed to hedges, their place within what were — to speak anachronically — agroforestry systems. Hedge's characteristics can be used to examine whether those who own or work the land adhere to traditional ideas or, on the contrary, whether they have broken with former practices. As a means of expression, hedges reveal the social value of agrarian landscapes.
- La vallée de Saint-Rivoal : un paysage au gré des hommes - Françoise Gestin p. 73-89 The Saint-Rivoal Valley : A Human Landscape In the Arrée Mountains (Britanny, France), the bocage has been conserved untouched. After clearing and then tilling the land, the people who settled in this area conserved a landscape that provides evidence of the material and social conditions with which they had to deal. Deeds, liege and land registries can be used to stratigraphically interpret and analyze the constitution of this landscape and to fix certain points in the gradual division of the land, sometimes only after the 17th century. Setting up, around the "ecological museum" in the Arrée Mountains (Regional Park of Armorica), a center for interpreting the landscape should make it possible to conduct experiments for dynamically conserving this heritage.
- La montagne des Suisses. Invention et usage d'une représentation paysagère (XVIIIe-XXe siècle) - François Walter p. 91-107 Swiss Mountains : Inventing and Using a Representation of the Landscape (18th-20th Century) This history of the process that crosses "spaciality" and "discursivity" at the point of identifying a type of landscape and its inhabitants (herein the Alps and Switzerland) shows how a set of places differentiated by use has served to gradually construct a landscape, which is to be interpreted in aesthetic and anthropological terms as of the 18th century, before it became mainly economic. In the case of Switzerland however, the "aestheticization" of the countryside into landscapes has been closely associated with building the nation during the 19th century, whence the necessity of an ideological sort of interpretation. Such is the problem of the chosen sites that landscapes represent as places of memory. Their production contrasts with another process, namely the diffusion of a Swiss ideal type of landscape and the misappropriation of a landscape, which gradually lost its symbolic contents throughout the 19th century.
- Le taillis contre la futaie. Différentes manières d'appréhender le paysage forestier ardennais - Agnès Fortier p. 109-126 Woods versus Underwood : Different Ways of Understanding the Ardennes Forest Landscape Is the forest a landscape ? An ethnographic survey of various categories of users (forest wardens, hunters, gatherers, holders of forest estovers, bird-catchers and women) was carried out in the wooded Ardennes mountains. It has shed light how people react to species of trees according to their knowledge, experiences, feelings and imaginary representations, which enter into the constitution of landscapes.
- Dossier : Perceptions du paysage dans le Domfrontais et évolution de l'espace rural - Nathalie Cadiou p. 127-139
- Paysage et altérité. En quête de "cultures paysagères" : réflexion méthodologique - Martin de La Soudière p. 141-150 Landscape and Otherness : A Quest for "Landscape Cultures", a Methodological Reflexion For the tourist or hiker just passing through, there is a landscape. But is the countryside a landscape for farmers who live there and live on the land ? Sociologists, ethnologists and geographers hold differing opinions about this. Examining how they respond to this question reveals the complexity of their relation to this subject of research. This complexity is expressed especially during field work, when the countryside in the field does not let the "scientist" indifferent. Whether the researcher is conscious or not of it, his observation of farmers' relationship to space interacts with his own "landscape culture". This article sheds light on what remains implicit in researchers' responses to the fore- mentioned question. The term "landscape" can then be defined unequivocally throughout a single text — thus avoiding the quid pro quos that too often occur in studies of the landscape as a social perception and representation.
- Débat : Les sociétés exotiques ont-elles des paysages ? - p. 151-158
- L'homme qui regardait l'homme qui regardait la mer - Jean-François Baré p. 159-168 The Man Who Watched the Man Watching the Sea This commentary on the painting View from Venus Point, Looking Eastwards by William Hodges (1744-1797), the Cook expedition's official painter, draws attention to the attitude of the figure contemplating the landscape — an attitude apparently similar to that of many contemporary rural Tahitians.
Le paysage en débat : points de vue et témoignages
- De la campagne à la "nature ordinaire". Génie écologique, paysages et traditions paysannes - Bernadette Lizet p. 169-184 From the Countryside to "Ordinary Nature" : Ecological Engineering, Landscapes and Peasant Traditions This study of the interrelations between landscape, environment and agriculture takes two complementary approaches : the "landscaping" of nature and the "decountrifying" of rural societies. The first seeks : to discover the theories and practices of ecological rural development in France and Europe ; to determine the political and legal authorities who codify the foregoing ; and to identify actors. The second approach seeks to understand how the countryside has been broken up and how ecological rural development has made folklore out of peasant traditions.
- Du pittoresque au "tout-paysage" - Bernard Kalaora, Martine Berlan-Darqué p. 185-195
- Le paysage : un patrimoine à gérer - Didier Bouillon p. 197-205 The Landscape : A Heritage to Manage Drawing up landscape policy for a regional park means choosing. Although parks may maintain a variety of options, values common to their policies can be singled out. To do this, we must have as clear an idea as possible about what is meant by the landscape and about its place in relation to a park's general policy. This implies objectives to be reached, priorities to be kept, and the means to be obtained to do all this : places, actions, partners. It carries a price in financial terms, of course, but also in terms of efforts and constraints. It is not always easy to assess this price which, beyond rhetorical incantations, is nonetheless a good indicator of the real value a social group sets on its landscape.
- Quelques aspects de la gestion paysagère de l'espace rural - Jacques Sgard p. 207-212
- La reconquête des paysages - Ségolène Royal p. 213-214
- Nuages de mort sur la péninsule de Kola - Noralv Veggeland p. 215-218
- De la campagne à la "nature ordinaire". Génie écologique, paysages et traditions paysannes - Bernadette Lizet p. 169-184
Chroniques scientifiques
- La problématique du paysage. État des lieux - Françoise Dubost p. 219-234 The Problem of the Landscape : An Inventory The landscape is now a fashionable topic. This is not the first time. Since the 1960s, this topic has been periodically revived, and then neglected. This accounts for much of the repetition in administrative and political authorities' current discourses — a criticism that also sometimes holds for scientific research. Herein, this research is placed in a historical perspective, and it is shown how different disciplines have contributed to this topic. Emphasis has been laid on themes shared by several disciplines. There are many obvious points of convergence. The basic paradigm has been redefined to take into account new issues about the landscape, in particular the rural landscape.
- De l'agriculture à l'environnement - Philippe Goergen p. 235-241
- La problématique du paysage. État des lieux - Françoise Dubost p. 219-234
Comptes rendus
- Héliane Bernard, La terre toujours réinventée. La France rurale et les peintres, 1920-1955. Une histoire de l'imaginaire. - Guillemin Alain p. 243-247
- Monique Pastor-Barrué et Michel Barrué, Architecture, élevage et société en montagne.Une expérience pilote de développement local dans les vallées pyrénéennes. - Cambrezy Luc p. 247-251
Lectures
Note critique
Chronique scientifique
- Campagnes françaises et britanniques - Bernard Kayser p. 265-270
Comptes rendus
- Robert Jacob, Les époux, le seigneur et la cité. Coutume et pratiques matrimoniales des bourgeois et paysans de France du Nord au moyen âge. - Desaive Jean-Paul p. 271-273
- Jon Mathieu, Eine Agrargeschichte der inneren Alpen. Graubünden, Tessin, Wallis 1500-1800. - Walter François p. 273-275
- Michel Demonet, Tableau de l'agriculture française au milieu du XIXe siècle, l'enquête de 1852. - Bonnain Rolande p. 275
- Philippe Grandcoing, La bande à Burgout et la société rurale de la Châtaigneraie limousine - p. 275-277
- Françoise Héritier-Augé et Elisabeth Copet-Rougier, Les complexités de l'alliance, t. 2 : Les systèmes complexes d'alliance matrimoniale. - Collard Chantal p. 277-280
- François Gresle, Michel Panoff, Michel Perrin, Pierre Tripier, Dictionnaire des sciences humaines. Sociologie, Psychologie sociale, Anthropologie. - Chamboredon Jean-Claude p. 280-283
- Marc Abélès, Jours tranquilles en 89. - Porqueres Enric p. 283-284
- Emmanuel Désveaux, Sous le signe de l'ours. Mythes et temporalité chez les Ojibwa septentrionaux. - Belmont Nicole p. 284-285
- Tina Jolas, Marie-Claude Pingaud, Françoise Zonabend, Yvonne Verdier, Une campagne voisine. - Pinton Solange p. 286-287
- Sylvain Maresca, L'autoportrait. Six agricultrices en quête d'image. - Lagrave Rose-Marie p. 287-288
- B. Etemad et J. Luciani, sous la dir. de P. Bairoch et J.-C. Toutain, Production mondiale d'énergie 1800-1985. - Martin Jean-Marie p. 289
- Résumés/Abstracts - p. 291-296