Contenu du sommaire : Locating Civil Society

Revue China perspectives Mir@bel
Numéro no 2012/3
Titre du numéro Locating Civil Society
Texte intégral en ligne Accessible sur l'internet
  • Special feature: Locating Civil Society: Communities Defending Basic Liberties

    • Introduction: Discussing “civil society” and “liberal communities” in China - Eva Pils p. 2-7 accès libre
    • Graduated Control and Beyond: The Evolving Government-NGO Relations - Fengshi Wu, Kin-man Chan p. 9-17 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
      Despite recent policy changes, governmental monitoring and control of grassroots NGOs remain pervasive and effective to a large extent in China. The enforcement of control over NGOs is complicated by at least three layers of factors: First, multiple agencies are involved in NGO control without a centralised norm. Second, government-NGO interactions vary across cases and are deeply rooted in local political contexts. Last, but not least, since the NGO community at its origin is highly diverse, NGOs' responses to various types of governmental control differ, which in turn triggers further complications. The main findings of this research are based on interviews with 60 NGO staff, as well as with civil affairs officials in Shanghai and Shenzhen from January 2011 to May 2012.
    • Media and civil society in China - Marina Svensson p. 19-28 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
      Although Chinese journalists are not able to create their own independent organisations, they are engaging in informal networking on-line and off-line that has created a strong sense of community among investigative journalists in particular.  Through sharing experiences, stories, and struggles, journalists create a collective identity and define their roles in society. Earlier studies of Chinese journalists haven't explicitly addressed the issue of how a journalistic community is created and sustained in a society that lacks freedom of the press and where freedom of association is severely restricted, and the importance of new information and communication technologies (ICTs) in this context, which is the focus of this article. Furthermore, it is important to study the extent to which and how investigative journalists network with other groups in society, including lawyers, public intellectuals, and civil society organisations. With the development of micro-blogging (weibo) we see new forms of community building, more open expressions of solidarity and ironic resistance, as well as increasing levels of interactivity between different groups in society. By reporting on injustices and the situation of marginalized groups in society, and commenting on public events on weibo, investigative journalists interact with many different groups in society and become part of a larger community of people who share the same ideals and struggles. Some journalists go one step further and set up or become actively involved in charity work and civil society organisations.
    • Rights Defence (weiquan), Microblogs (weibo), and Popular Surveillance (weiguan) - Teng Biao p. 29-39 avec résumé en anglais
      The rise of China's rights defence movement has occurred in tandem with the rapid development of the Internet in China. Various forms of rights defence inside and outside of the courtroom have emerged and developed alongside changes to China's ideological, political, and legal systems and social structure. Similarly, Internet technology such as microblogs and other social media are enriching the modalities of activity in the rights defence movement, enhancing the mobilisation capacity of activists, and accelerating the systematisation of popular rights defence, profoundly affecting China's ongoing political transformation.
    • Protestant Christianity and Civil Society in Authoritarian China - Carsten T. Vala p. 43-52 avec résumé en anglais
      Religious groups can reinforce, complement, or undermine authoritarian domination. This article investigates whether high-status Protestant churches act as democratising civil society organisations by gathering hundreds of Protestants openly outside state structures to change church registration policies. In so doing, they also seek to curtail state domination over religion and, by extension, over all groups in society.
    • Western Funding for Rule of Law Initiatives in China: - Thomas E. Kellogg p. 53-59 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
      Recent research has suggested that Western donors working in China have channelled most of their funds to government-affiliated entities, including state-affiliated think tanks, academic institutions, and government agencies, rather than to grassroots civil society organisations. A more state-centred approach may have made sense in the early years of the reform era, when few non-governmental organisations existed in China that could serve as effective partners to Western donors. Yet the rapid growth and development of the civil society sector in China over the last several years means that a number of new actors are doing very important work on a range of issues related to human rights and the rule of law. The author argues that Western funding for newly-formed grassroots civil society organisations is crucial to the ongoing development of Chinese civil society. In addition, because grassroots groups can often make fuller use of key advocacy tools, such as interest group mobilisation, media advocacy, and strategic litigation, they may in some cases be even more effective in pursuing progressive goals than academic or government-affiliated entities. Western donors active in China should take note of the rapidly-changing civil society landscape in China and make efforts to ensure that their funding strategies are in line with the evolving country context.
  • Article

    • The Snow Dragon: China's Strategies in the Arctic - Olga Alexeeva, Frédéric Lasserre p. 61-68 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
      In recent years, several analyses and news media articles have predicted a resurgence of tensions in the Arctic over access to maritime space. Among the contenders involved in this potential struggle is China, whose ambitions in the region are suspected to hold a destabilising potential. Yet, as Beijing is developing its policy towards the region, it remains unclear whether it will contest the claims over maritime access of countries bordering the Arctic and forcibly take over parts of the region for resource extraction purposes.
  • Current Affairs

    • Is Xi Jinping the Reformist Leader China Needs? - Jean-Pierre Cabestan p. 69-76 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
      In autumn 2012, following the 18th Congress of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), Xi Jinping is to succeed Hu Jintao as General Secretary of the Party and also, in all probability, as Chairman of the Central Military Commission, where he has been second-in-command since 2010. In March 2013, he is set to become President of the People's Republic of China. Born into the political elite, he enjoys a great deal of support in the Nomenklatura. Having governed several coastal provinces, the current Vice-President is thoroughly acquainted with the workings of Party and state. He also has support within the Army, where he spent a short time at the beginning of his career. In addition, in recent years, he has acquired significant international experience. Urbane and affable, Xi is appreciated for his consensual approach.  Nonetheless, Xi is taking charge of the country at a particularly delicate time. China is having to adopt an alternative growth model whilst the government is struggling with powerful economic and regional feudalities. The Bo Xilai affair has highlighted the weakening of the central government, the corruption of the elites, and deep-rooted ideological differences within the Party machine that are damaging the political legitimacy of the regime and endangering its stability. As a result, Xi must not onlyreunify the Party leadership and machine but also establish his authority over all the country's civil and military institutions. His style and charisma will help him. But his success will also and above all depend on his ability to form a united coalition set on reform and capable of dismantling the privileges acquired by the regime's many bosses. The CCP needs a leader who is both strong and courageous. Is Xi such a man? Perhaps.
    • CEFC News Analysis
    • China Analysis
      • Reforming China's Criminal Procedure Law - Hugo Winckler p. 80-82 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
        Sources:- Wang Jianxun, “The provisions of the reform of criminal procedural law legalising secret investigations are a step backwards,” Caijing wang, 5 September 2011.- Chen Youxi, “The legalisation of secret investigations is an important violation of political integrity,” Zhongguo wangluo dianshitai – CNTV web site, Opinion section, 27 November 2011.- Wu Zhehua, “Chen Weidong discusses reform of the criminal procedure law: Behind each article there is a story,” Zhongguoguangbo wang, 8 March 2012.- Chen Guangzhong, “The provisions of the great reform of [China's] criminal procedure law represent progress,” Jinghua Shibao – Beijing Times, 9 March 2012.- Xie Doudou, Wang Heyan, “The vicissitudes of the clause on secret detention,” Caixin wang, 12 March 2012.- “A focus on the great reform of criminal procedure law: Important perspectives on the ‘little constitution',” Banyuetan wang, 13 March 2012.- Li Xiangning and Xu Kai, “Criminal procedure law amendment passes amid controversy,” Caijing, 25 March 2012.- Yao Dongxing, “Behind the scenes of the ‘great reform': Four protagonists' narratives about ten years of power games,” Zhongguo jingji zhoukan – China Economic Weekly, 27 March 2012.
      • Local governments under pressure: The commodification of stability maintenance - Jérôme Doyon p. 80-82 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
        Sources:- Xu Kai and Li Wei'ao, “The stability maintaining machine,” Caijing, 6 June 2011.- Zhong Weijun, “The ‘zero-incident' logic of local governments in maintaining stability: An analytical framework,” Zhejiang shehui kexue – Zhejiang social sciences, no. 9, September 2011.- Gao Jun, “The trap of maintaining stability and how to avoid it,” Lilun daokan, no. 11, 2011.- Xia Nan, “The alienation of weiwen,” Caijing, 12 October 2011.- Zhang Qianfan, “The origin and disruption of the system for petitioning the higher authorities,” Tansuo yu zhengming – Exploration and free views, 10 May 2012.
  • Book Reviews