Contenu du sommaire : An annual english selection

Revue Revue Française de Sociologie Mir@bel
Numéro Vol. 42, Supplément 2001
Titre du numéro An annual english selection
Texte intégral en ligne Accessible sur l'internet
  • Editor's note - p. 3-4 accès libre
  • Forty years of social mobility in France : change in social fluidity in the light of recent models - Louis-André Vallet, Kevin Riley p. 5-64 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    The aim of this paper is to examine whether a long-term trend can be identified in the mobility regime of French society from the middle of the century. It begins with a review of the international literature on temporal trends in social fluidity within modern societies. Analysing recent French research which has concluded that inequality of opportunity has remained unchanged in France during the last two decades, the paper argues that such a conclusion can only have resulted from the use of insufficiently powerful statistical techniques. The second part of the paper analyses father-son and father-daughter mobility tables drawn from national representative surveys carried out in 1953, 1970, 1977, 1985 and 1993 (N=35,741 for males and 18,484 for females). The use of log-linear and log-multiplicative models reveals that the statistical association (as measured with the logarithm of the odds ratio) between social origin and destination has declined steadily by 0.5 % a year over a period of forty years. This finding highlights a slow but continuous trend towards a reduction in inequality of opportunity from the middle of the century. Of the twelve million French men and women between the ages of 35 and 59 who were in employment in 1993, nearly half a million would have belonged to different classes without this forty year increase in social fluidity. The paper concludes that the thesis of temporal invariance in the intergenera- tional mobility regime cannot be maintained for France, but that the reasons of this change still remain to be ascertained.
  • Temporal stratification of taste : the social diffusion of first names - Philippe Besnard, Guy Desplanques p. 65-77 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    Because it involves objectifying esthetic preferences in official records, parents' choice of name for their newborn child is one of the best materials for empirically testing the classical hypothesis of vertical social diffusion of taste. The present study is based on a representative sample (N=367,000) of first names of persons born in France between 1930 and 1988. The proportion of innovative choice (i.e., choice made at the very beginning of the diffusion process) in the various socio-occupational categories provides an indicator for a temporal hierarchy of taste. This hierarchy, which corresponds closely to the nomenclature of socio-occupational categories used by the French national statistics institute Insee (Institut national de la statistique et des études économiques), tends to become compressed over time. To grasp the full meaning of the temporal stratification of taste, the hierarchy obtained with this indicator is compared to those for the various standard dimensions of social stratification.
  • A revolution in representations of work : the emergence over the 19th century of the statistical category "occupied population" in France, Great Britain, and the United States - Christian Topalov p. 79-106 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    The division of a country's population into occupied and unoccupied persons -a distinction that stands as the common foundation for socio-occupational classifications that vary from country to country- seems so widely used and generally accepted as to be almost invisible. The strangeness of this solid construct, however, invites us to examine the long and difficult process that culminated, in the late nineteenth century, with the adoption of a definition of "being occupied" based on a single criterion : the marketability of a person's labor. This neglected aspect of census history enables us to shed light on the nature and diverse national rhythms of a development which it is not excessive to regard as a revolution in statistical representations of work.
  • An unlikely mobilization : the occupation of Saint-Nizier church by the prostitutes of Lyon - Lilian Mathieu p. 107-131 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    This article examines the conditions under which, in June 1975, a marginalized, stigmatized population -the prostitutes of the French city of Lyon- took the step of collective action, occupying a church for more than a week to protest against police repression. It highlights the difficulties these politically inexperienced women encountered in mobilizing, namely preventing defections and choosing an appropriate mode of action ; difficulties they were able to surmount thanks to resources provided by outside supporters endowed with practical knowledge in matters of collective action (activists in a group with close ties to the broad movement known as catholicisme social and feminists). Despite this assistance, however, the prostitutes' mobilization quickly declined and soon expired, in part because of the leaders' defection.
  • Measuring crime : police statistics and victimisation surveys (1985-1995) - Philippe Robert, Renée Zauberman, Marie-Lys Pottier, Hugues Lagrange p. 133-174 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
    For many years, measuring crime on the sole basis of computations of the operations of the public agencies in charge of its control implied great implicit confidence in the adequacy of their action to expectations for safety-maintenance. Over the last thirty years, all comparable countries have gradually come to resort at least partially to surveys, revealing their increasing doubts about this adequacy. In 1996 the Insee [the French national institute for statistics} inserted a module on victimisation in its survey of the living conditions of households, thus yielding an opportunity to measure medium-term variations from one decade to another, for the first time in France. Comparison of these findings with the only national survey available so far (Cesdip, 1986) shows how different the picture is for violence and property offences, in terms of numbers and of trends. It is also possible to evaluate the extent -variable, depending on the kinds of victimisation- to which official statistics still reliably account for trends as well as for orders of magnitude. Aside from its methodological teaching, this analysis modifies and clarifies present controversies over crime.
  • Review essay

    • Around Dominique Monjardet's Sociologie de la force publique : recent books and articles in French in the field of sociology of the police - Pierre Favre p. 175-186 accès libre avec résumé en anglais
      In 1997 and 1998 several books were published in French on the sociology of the police. Two of these works, both published in Quebec, have essentially practical or programmatic aims ; a collection in homage to Lode Van Outrive, published in Belgium, contains only a few articles on the police, some of outstanding quality. Finally, the work published in France by D. Monjardet, the most important French sociologist of the police, offers a remarkable synthesis of twelve years of research. Using a truly exemplary sociological approach, Monjardet analyzes the characteristics of police work and the police profession in France, demonstrating the weakness of the political authority's control over the police and elucidating the mechanisms that give the police its considerable operational freedom within society. At present Monjardet's work is the main French reference in this field, one that is developing considerably in France.